The Indepedent
16 January 2002
CONCORDIA
WIGMORE HALL 9 Janaury 2002
This coming May sees the 400th anniversary of the birth of
one of Britain’s most striking composers – although as recently as half a
century ago, few would have recognised William Lawes as such. Only since
then have scholars and performers gradually disinterred from the archives a
full range of the consort and vocal music, which was composed, in all its
richness and strangeness, over a mere couple of decades by this loyal
servant (unto death) of Charles I.
Just how rich and strange was immediately manifest in an
exceptionally cogent concert devised by Mark Levy, leader of that
accomplished viol consort Concordia, for the opening evening of their Lawes
anniversary series at the Wigmore Hall.
Dispensing with the kind of verse-readings from the
period, lecturettes on "historical background" and whatnot that are all too
usual in such programmes, this one made its points musically. The matching
of consort music and vocal settings by Lawes with equivalent pieces by his
great predecessor, William Byrd, and successor, Henry Purcell, positively
dramatised the contrast between their settled mastery and his passionate,
almost experimental daring.
Three of Lawes’s Setts, or suites, for six viols with
chamber organ continuo provided the programme’s spine: music alternately of
volatile feeling and fathomless sonority. Compared with the down-to-earth
logic of Byrd’s Fantasy a 6 in G minor, or the elegant partwriting of
Purcell’s Fantasy on one note, Concordia’s account of the opening Fantazy
from Lawes’s Sett a 6 in F major luxuriated in his propensity to dissolve
counterpoint into sheer texture, emphasising the chiming interference
patterns between parts – in this instance, majestic chains of descending
thirds – just as their reading of the second Fantazy in the same Sett made
the most if its almost bar-by-bar shifts of mood and unaccountable final
switch from ebullience to tragedy.
For the vocal items, various members of Concordia were
joined by the seraphic countertenor Robin Blaze. Here, in comparison with,
especially, Purcell’s infallible ear fro English word-setting, Lawes’s
efforts occasionally sounded a mite awkward – in his canticle "When Man for
Sin Thy Judgement Feels", for instance.
And though Blaze found a searing conviction in its
refrain, his serene radiance in Purcell’s "An Evening Hymn" was quite
something else. All the same, the next Lawes concert in 24 January, in which
Concordia are joined by Emma Kirkby, is absolutely not to be missed.
BAYAN NORTHCOTT
© Independent 2002